In many science and engineering fields that require computational models to predict certain physical quantities, we are often faced with the selection of the best model under the constraint that only a small sample set can be physically measured. One such example is the prediction of human perception of visual quality, where sample images live in a high dimensional space with enormous content variations. We propose a new methodology for model comparison named group maximum differentiation (gMAD) competition. Given multiple computational models, gMAD maximizes the chances of falsifying a "defender" model using the rest models as "attackers". It exploits the sample space to find sample pairs that maximally differentiate the attackers while holding the defender fixed. Based on the results of the attacking-defending game, we introduce two measures, aggressiveness and resistance, to summarize the performance of each model at attacking other models and defending attacks from other models, respectively. We demonstrate the gMAD competition using three examples—image quality, image aesthetics, and streaming video quality-of-experience. Although these examples focus on visually discriminable quantities, the gMAD methodology can be extended to many other fields, and is especially useful when the sample space is large, the physical measurement is expensive and the cost of computational prediction is low.

@article{ma2020group,
  author    = {Ma, Kede and Duanmu, Zhengfang and Wang, Zhou and Wu, Qingbo and Liu, Wentao and Yong, Hongwei and Li, Hongliang and Zhang, Lei}, 
  title     = {Group Maximum Differentiation Competition: Model Comparison with Few Samples}, 
  journal   = {IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence},
  volume    = {42},
  number    = {4},
  pages     = {851-864},
  month     = {Apr.},
  year      = {2020}
}
              

@inproceeding{ma2016gmad,
  author    = {Ma, Kede and Wu, Qingbo and Wang, Zhou and Duanmu, Zhengfang and Yong, Hongwei and Li, Hongliang and Zhang, Lei}, 
  title     = {Group {MAD} Competition - A New Methodology to Compare Objective Image Quality Models}, 
  booktitle = {IEEE Conferene on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition},
  pages     = {1664--1673},
  year      = {2016}
}